Order Now Order Now
Login / SignUp
Order Now

Home Free Essays

>>

All Subjects

>>

Education

>>

None

None

Download

Describe the dispute that led to New York Times v. Sullivan and how the court resolved it.

The defendant, a famous newspaper agency, published an ad promoting donations defending Martin Luther King Jr. on perjury charges. Since the publication consisted of many flaws concerning facts, the plaintiff, who was the then Public Safety Commissioner, requested in writing to publicly retract the information. The defendant, however, refused leading to a legal case based on libel action. The plaintiff was awarded the plaintiff $500,000 in damages by the State Court. State Supreme Court affirmed. The decision was appealed.

Explain the historical context and reasoning of the court.

As per the First Amendment, the onus of proof remains on plaintiff, in a libelous case, to provide evidence concerning that it was in the knowledge of the defendant that he/she was false or reckless in publishing the statement. The court reasoned that for libel, it is not important to prove that the statement was false but to indicate that it had been published within a false intention.

Why did the court make it harder for public officials to win liberal cases than private individuals?

The claims of libel by public officials rarely prevail due to the extremely high burden of proof on the plaintiff to provide evidence concerning that it was in the knowledge of the defendant that he/she was false or reckless in publishing the statement. For this reason, the court made it harder for public officials to win liberal cases than private individuals.

What is the courts test for determining if a claim against a public official is libelous?

The court determines that if the claim made against a public official is libelous through an evidentiary standard midway between ‘by preponderance of evidence’ and ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’. It is the rule of clear and convincing proof. In practice, it remains closer to reasonable doubt instead of preponderance of evidence, which means 99-percent to 100-percent certainty whereas reasonable doubt indicates 51-percent clarity.

Do you think the court gives journalist too much room for mistakes?

In the case under discussion, the First Amendment would have been of no use if little or no breathing space had given to controversial reports containing unintentional mistakes. However, the mistakes must be made without the element of malice.

More Subjects

Education

(5614)

English

(2294)

Business And Management

(1760)

Healthcare And Nursing

(1684)

Psychology

(929)

History And Anthropology

(743)

Sociology

(572)

IT

(446)

Education

(429)

Finance, Accounting And Banking

(419)

Philosophy

(347)

Political Science

(310)

Law And International Law

(308)

HRM

(300)

Economics

(288)

Biology And Life Sciences

(267)

Literature

(249)

Marketing And PR

(238)

Culture

(140)

Environmental Science

(109)

Geography

(92)

Statistics

(64)

Maths

(53)

International Relations

(44)

Physics

(30)

Chemistry

(25)

Capstone

(8)

Project Management

(8)

Reflective Thinking

(7)

Critical Review

(3)

Linguistics

(3)

Critical Appraisal

(2)

BUS 2090

(2)

English 12 Drama

(1)

Business Information Technology

(1)

Operational Plan

(1)

Corporate Finance

(1)

L2 Photography And Design

(1)

Food Nutrition

(1)

Leadership

(1)

Nursing

(1)

MBA

(1)

Social Enterprise Project

(1)

Government

(1)

Our tools

Essay typer Grammar Checker Plagiarism Checker Citation Generator

Useful Links

Free Essays About Blog

Contact me

info@freeessaywriter.net

If you have any queries please write to us

Join our mailing list

Invalid Email Address!
Thank you for joining our mailing list

Please note that some of the content on our website is generated using AI and it is thoroughly reviewed and verified by our team of experienced editors. The essays and papers we provide are intended for learning purposes only and should not be submitted as original work.

@ All Rights Reserved 2023 info@freeessaywriter.net

Privacy Policy Terms of Service Use Contact
Back to top