Essay Review

Your Name

Instructor Name

Course Number

Date

Essay Review

Author’s Main Argument

Burns writes, “The pastoral relationship became increasingly tense as new notions of authority emerged from the Second Vatican Council. Of central concern to younger priests were issues of authority within the parish and the rectory. Indeed, underlying the growing “generation gap” was the question of authority and the subsequent difference in generational expectations, both issues that ran like fault lines throughout the 1960s”. (52)

Explanation of Primary Sources

It is crucial to examine and critically explain different primary sources used by the researcher to defend his argument in this research article. Different forms such as diaries, journals, and legal documents, etc. were considered by the useful source of information to make his argument valid and successful. The content from the original book, “The Revolt of the Cockroach People” written by Oscar Zeta Acosta used by the researcher to illustrated the changing prospect of the Mexican American Catholic community. Inclusion of this specific source ultimately helps to identify the specific historical grounds that eventually leads to the conflict of the authority. Valuable information shared by Father John Sandersfled in the interview was also utilized by the researcher to explain the actual context of the Sandersfled incident. The transcript of the interview of Eugene Boyle is another primary source of information used by the author to critically explain the main argument of the article.

Relatedness of Article with Lectures

The growing concern of the transformation of the church is critically discussed by the author in this research article. The main focus of the researcher is to address the increasing trend of the generation gap that is appeared in the case of young priests. The emergence of religious practices needs to be comprehensively addressed to attain better approach of consensus. The arguments presented in the article eventually helps to understand the emergence of religion in different periods of time. It is valuable step to create better communication prospect between senior and young priests to eliminate the problems of the community and the rectory. Development of new philosophies in case of emerging authorities somehow conflict with the conventional religious approach. It is one serious theological concern that requires necessary attention and develops some necessary and suitable communication channels.

It is vital to indicate that religious concern raised by the researcher eventually associated with different relevant aspects. These features can be observed in the case of two different approaches of church significantly in the forms of consideration of church, discipline, respect, duty, and style. Critical understanding of the Sandersfeld event is essential to examine the growing concern of conflict between conventional and contemporary approaches of theology. The lectures on religious studies eventually help to focus on the emerging role of church and pastors due to different developments. Critical consideration of the Sandersfeld incident is one significant approach to examine the existing gap between the younger clergy and the elder clergy. This domain of understanding is also critical to examine the perspective of changing religious ideologies and practices. The emergence of theological philosophies during the specific time-period is also related to the argument presented by the author in the considered article. The evidence provided by the researcher in this article is one effective source of information to examine the significance of the transitional period of the 1960s ADDIN ZOTERO_ITEM CSL_CITATION {"citationID":"AZH7mONk","properties":{"formattedCitation":"(Burns)","plainCitation":"(Burns)","noteIndex":0},"citationItems":[{"id":1273,"uris":["http://zotero.org/users/local/7Hi3kAOD/items/YZWHMSA9"],"uri":["http://zotero.org/users/local/7Hi3kAOD/items/YZWHMSA9"],"itemData":{"id":1273,"type":"article-journal","title":"Priests in Revolt: The San Francisco Association of Priests, 1968-1971","container-title":"US Catholic Historian","page":"51-68","volume":"26","issue":"3","author":[{"family":"Burns","given":"Jeffrey M."}],"issued":{"date-parts":[["2008"]]}}}],"schema":"https://github.com/citation-style-language/schema/raw/master/csl-citation.json"} (Burns 52). Detailed understanding of the crisis of authority in this time-period is vital to identify the actual development of the theological perspective.

Relatedness of Articles with Readings

The question of the generation gap in the context of pastors highlighted by the author in this article is also closely related to the different readings of the development of theology. It is a vital approach to identify different aspects of religious transition over the years to identify different aspects of religious ideas, respect, and style, etc. Exploration of different school of thoughts about religious development is essential step to identify the emerging domain of theology. The details about the Sandersfled event is one helpful medium to identify the prevailing gaps between the approaches of traditional priests and young priests in case of different religious thoughts and practices. The content of this article is also one suitable approach to effectively determine the overall development of the Catholic Church in the country. The argument presented by the author in this article ultimately helps to understand the content of all the readings related to the development of religious philosophies over the years. This specific article is one useful source of information when it comes to the assessment of the authority that happened in the 1960s. Detailed understanding of the historical domain of theology is a necessary condition to examine the perspective of authority in different forms of social, political, religious, and cultural domains. It is vital to examine how the deteriorating facets of authority in this scenario can cause growing conflict between traditional and modern theological approach. The details provided by researcher is one significant approach to particularly examine the paradigms of disintegration and invalidation in the scenario of the role of authority.

Contribution of Article in the Field of Theology

Critical analysis of the article can never be considered complete without defining its connection with the overall study of theology. It is vital to observe the significant influence of the researcher’s argument on the overall domain of theology. It is critical to indicate that this article is one useful source of information to understand the transitional approach of religion over the years. It assists to examine that growing conflict between old and new pastors ultimately cause the transformation of theological ideologies in a great manner. Identification of revolt by priests is a primitive idea to analyze the changing perspectives of the specific time period of 1968 to 1971. This particular article is one crucial source of information to examine the transitional period of the 1060s in the country particularly in the context of the transitional role of authority.

The comprehensive information about the Sandersfled incident is one critical source of information to identify the specific ideological gap that existed between traditional and younger clergy. This source of information is vital to determine the changing role of authority in different social, political, and religious domains. Assessment of the event of the 1960s helps to examine the catholic history of the country as there was the existence of two different understanding forms of church and the overall religious disciplines. Consideration of the incident of the 1960s also helps to recognize the existence of the problematic relationship between priests and their associates. This event is one clear indication that the relationship between different authorities was one problematic aspect as it starts questioning the involvement of the authority. Identification of different aspects of the generation gap in the content of theological domain is crucial to makes better inferences about the development of the contemporary approach of the authority. Proper examination of the conflict of authority in the context of 1960s is critical to establish a better understanding of the practical implications of the theological ideas and philosophies. It is rightly said by the researcher that it was the time of hope and conflict for the citizens as it offers different forms of authority. It was the time-period of development and different ideological changes that ultimately influenced the role of Church and the priests.

Works Cited

ADDIN ZOTERO_BIBL {"uncited":[],"omitted":[],"custom":[]} CSL_BIBLIOGRAPHY Burns, Jeffrey M. “Priests in Revolt: The San Francisco Association of Priests, 1968-1971.” US Catholic Historian, vol. 26, no. 3, 2008, pp. 51–68.